5 min read

Weekly Combine Newsletter: Worry over UK Minister Wimbledon/Medvedev comments

Weekly Combine Newsletter: Worry over UK Minister Wimbledon/Medvedev comments

A UK Minister who said Russian tennis players- including world-number-1 Daniil Medvedev- may be kept out of Wimbledon if they do not provide anti-Putin "assurances", has drawn a response from scholars, policy experts and ex-players alike suggesting that is a step too far in punishing athletes who have family members in Russia that could be put at risk by such statements.

Earlier this week, British Sports Minister Nigel Huddleston told a UK Parliament Select Committee- in a question specifically aimed at Medvedev's Wimbledon participation- he may seek assurances he and other Russian players do not support the Ukraine invasion.

"Absolutely nobody flying the flag for Russia should be allowed or enabled," said Huddleston.

"We need some potential assurance that they are not supporters of Putin and we are considering what requirements we may need to try and get some assurances along those lines."

The Minister said discussions were in place with Wimbledon organisers about potential measures, and he also cited possible visa implications for those athletes entering Britain.

The men's and women's tennis federations had previously announced that individual athletes can compete under the neutral banner whilst Russian teams have been withdrawn from competitions, and the nation's membership suspended. That means Medvedev and other top female and male players will be able to compete individually at tournaments, including the upcoming French Open and Wimbledon.

As expected, the ITF, ATP and WTA decision has attracted criticism for not going far enough and pressure to take further action. Ukrainian WTA player Marat Kostyuk said she disagrees with the comparatively moderate stance not to ban Russian athletes, citing the hurt their presence causes and her view Russian players have not spoken out enough against the war.

However, the suggested Wimbledon approach by Minister Huddleston would not be to ban Russian players outright but rather somehow force them to pledge "assurances" that they in no way support the Russian Government before being permitted to compete.

That suggestion is causing concern among commentators considering Russia's draconian laws on public speech and the real possibility of repercussions against players' family members, like Medvedev's, who still remain in Russia.

Whilst there is a view among some experts that sporting sanctions, especially against Russian teams, have merit, they do not apply so freely to the very individual sport of tennis.

“I don’t think you should ask them to be more vocal about it because they have family to consider, and now, you know, they can get 15 years in prison for talking about the war,” Martina Navratilova told the New York Times in an interview.

No formal announcements have been made by the French or UK authorities in relation to any further restrictions on Russian athletes. The joint ITF, ATP and WTA statement of 1 March 2022 still stands and is unlikely to be changed unless those organisations are forced to do so.

"I feel very strongly that these individual athletes should not be the ones that are being penalised by the decisions of an authoritarian leadership that is obviously doing terrible, reprehensible things," WTA Chairman and CEO Steve Simon told the BBC earlier this week.

As Medvedev said himself referencing the issue after a recent match at the Indian Wells tournament

"Let's see how the situation evolves."


Sports Law Combine now provides our weekly combine newsletter by email to all members. To unlock access to all our articles, click here for details about our individual or business subscriptions.

If you missed our latest articles, here are Sports Law Combine's published articles from the past seven days.

Wild MLB week sees lockout end, but League’s antitrust exemption faces scrutiny
Former Presidential candidate Sen. Bernie Sanders is among United States Senators still calling for an end to the MLB’s controversial and long-held antitrust exemption. Despite the MLB and the Players’ Union’s just-brokered tentative agreement, that will see the end of what looked an inevitable- at…
Russian Olympic Committee launch CAS appeal against Youth Olympic exclusion
The Russian Olympic Committee (‘ROC’) has filed an appeal over the decision to prevent Russian athletes from competing in March’s Winter European Youth Olympic Festival, in another Russian appeal to the Court of Arbitration for Sport (‘CAS’) against a sanction excluding Russian athletes over the ong…
Review of the FIFA Annual Law Review: Buenos Aires, Argentina
FIFA Legal’s upcoming focus will be tuned to the European Super League legal battle, the early stages of the operation of the Football Tribunal and stamping out sexual misconduct, according to the fourth edition of the FIFA Law Annual Review (‘law review’) held in Buenos Aires last week. In a
CAS deny Russian stay request over UEFA football ban
Russia’s hopes of participating in upcoming world football matches have been severely dented as the Court of Arbitration for Sport (‘CAS’) denied the Football Union of Russia (‘FUR’) application for a stay against the decision to ban Russian teams and clubs from UEFA competition. The CAS announced i…
No appeal yet for Blessing Okagbare after 10-year ban in systematic doping scheme
The Nigerian sprinter Blessing Okagbare has yet to appeal her 10-year doping suspension, despite the time limit to do so expiring this week. The decision to ban her was based on a proportional response to her “egregious” and “aggravating” conduct, as revealed in the recently published full decision…

© Copyright 2022 Sports Law Combine